Menu contact

Grenoble, France

L'Isle d'Abeau - Reduction of running costs in social housing through energy and water saving

The extensive retrofit programme of 6 buildings built in 1984 with 110 social dwellings in Grenoble, France aims to demonstrate the possibilities of renewable energies and water saving measures.

The buildings were erected in the seventies and eighties, and can thus represent a good example to many other European cities with similar buildings together with social and ecological problems.
The project is located in L’Isle d’Abeau, a town 30 km from Lyon in the Rhone Alpe region.

The dwellings have high running costs, so the retrofit programme will beside the elevated level of comfort generate decreased expenses on water and energy, which is an important beneficial side effect in social housing.

In these buildings there were a lot of turnover and a high vacancy rate because of the high level of maintenance costs for heat (electric heating) and for domestic hot water. Through the retrofit programme, the intention was to reduce maintenance costs with an improvement of quality of life and treatment of all environmental aspects.

The combination of both environmental and social benefits from the project is of particular interest, as many housing projects tend to focus merely on improvement of comfort and less on societal impact.

It is aimed to demonstrate the possibilities to reduce maintenance costs in social housing with renewable energies, energy saving and water saving and to improve the situation of inhabitants. Most of them have economic difficulties. The aim is to reach affordable costs.

The retrofit programme stands out as a total environmental approach, which aims to lower the energy consumption by some 40% through enhanced heating systems and education of end users.

Firstly electricity for heating is replaced by natural gas with two optimised combustion central boilers that are regulated according to heat demand. The boilers are supplemented by 165 m2 of solar water collection panels mounted on the roof and high performance heat exchangers, and the entire system, including pipe structure and pumps, is optimised by a total energy approach. 48 m2 of photovoltaic modules for ventilation and low energy lighting in common areas are integrated in the roof of the buildings.

Communication with end users about possibilities of energy saving is highlighted as crucial to the success of the project, since user behaviour has high impact on energy consumption.
The total maintenance costs were aimed to be decreased by 35%. This is a very important demonstration because a lot of old buildings in Europe, notably social housing buildings have high maintenance costs linked with social problems.

It is the intention that the project will serve as an educational process for builders and consultants, which can facilitate the dissemination of knowledge on environmental technologies.

OPAC 38 has a social mission: to provide accommodation for people with low incomes. That is why, one of its goals, is to reduce the couple “rent + maintenance charges”. This project also aims to demonstrate the benefits of renewable energies and energy management regarding the maintenance costs reduction.

Generel information on the technologies:
Condensing Gas boiler

Solar water collectors

PV modules

Ventilation and Heat Exchange

Monitoring Scheme:

Building period: Work started: June 2002
Work finised: June 2003
Monitoring period: October - June 2004
Monitoring results: 110 dwellings
For heating a preliminary monitoring period from October to December 2003 shows:
  • 13.5% less gas consumption compared to OPAC 38’s other buildings.
  • 25% lower consumption for domestic hot water compared to OPAC 38’s other buildings.
Other Results/ archievements Although there were some problems when the installation was started up, it is now running efficiently. The acceptance by the tenants is obtained. They feel an improvement of their comfort, especially for heating, and they are very satisfied with the reduction in maintenance costs. The overheating due to the former glass roof is also often mentioned. The inside hall is now a comfortable place for the tenants to meet.

In order to ensure a good running of the installation, a meeting was organised in September 2003 in order to give some specific information to the tenants. A French association for the promotion of renewable energies (AGEDEN) organised also individual meetings with the tenants, to explain to them how they can reduce their energetic bill.

The heating and the DHW are produced with gas bought at 25.96 €/MWh. The maintenance for the heating costs 6,536 Euro/year and for the DHW 4,228 Euro/year. Finally the renting of the individual DHW meters costs 21 Euro/dwelling.
Thanks to the solar production, the DHW production only costs 2.97 Euro/m3 while it is 5.23 Euro/m3 in average in OPAC 38’s other dwellings; which corresponds to a 57% reduction.

Regarding total operational costs the achieved savings is approx. 61% - see table below:
 
Costs in € Before work After work
Energy costs 109,482 31,382
Maintenance 3,410 13,074
Total costs 112,892 44,456
scheme

Further information:

Builder







 
OPAC 38
Mr. Michel Gibert
47, av Marie Reynoard
F-38035 Grenoble Cédex 2
France
Phone: +33-476205140
Fax: +33-476205147
E-mail: mgibert@opac38.fr
www.opac38.fr
Architects DUO
Ms. Giacometti
Centr'alp, 137 rue Mayoussard
F-38430 Moirans
Phone:+33-476351919
Fax:+33-476351918
Technical consultants ENERPOL
Mr GUERRY
149 rue Alexandre Bérard
F-01500 Ambérieu en Bugey
Phone: +33-474345959
Fax: +33-474382978

GIRUS
Mr. LACAZE
21 avenue du Granier
F-38240 Meylan
Phone: +33-437452910
Project location L'Isle d'Abeau
12 rue Hôtel de Ville
F-38080 L'Isle d'Abeau
Phone: +33-474182000

Members